Comparison

    Broker 360 vs Spreadsheets

    The thing a CRM actually replaces is often not another CRM. It is a spreadsheet, a notes app and a good memory. That spreadsheet deserves credit: it is free, it is yours, and it has probably survived two carriers and one agency change. The question is not whether it works — it is which jobs it is still the right tool for.

    7 days free. A card is required to start, nothing is charged before day 7, and every plan is month to month after that.

    Broker 360 is a mobile-first CRM for independent life, health, final expense and Medicare agents, their managers and agency owners. This page is an honest job-by-job comparison, and it is fine if the answer for some of those jobs is still the sheet.

    Broker 360 at a glance
    Who it's forIndependent life, health, final expense and Medicare agents, managers and agency owners
    PlatformsiPhone, iPad, Android, and the web dashboard at broker360pro.com
    Price fromAgent $49/month · month to month
    Free trial7 days, card required, nothing charged before day 7
    Getting your data inUpload a CSV and review the matches; done-for-you import on the Plus plans

    What a spreadsheet is genuinely good at

    This is not a straw man. There are jobs a blank grid does better than any product, including ours.

    A spreadsheet is the best ad-hoc calculator ever made. Modelling a comp grid, splitting a bonus between two agents, sanity-checking a carrier statement, working out whether a nine-month advance on a $92 monthly premium is worth chasing — a sheet does all of that in thirty seconds, in exactly the shape you want, with no feature request.

    It is also completely yours. No subscription, no login, no vendor who could change the product. For a brand-new agent writing four policies a month, a sheet is honestly a reasonable system, and anyone who tells you otherwise is selling something.

    Plenty of agents who move their book into a CRM keep a spreadsheet for exactly these jobs. That is the right outcome, not a failure.

    Where it stops keeping up

    A sheet is a ledger. The trouble starts when you ask a ledger to be a reminder system, a map and a team dashboard at the same time.

    It does not know what day it is. A spreadsheet will hold a "call back in 90 days" note forever without ever mentioning it again. Everything time-based depends on you opening the file and sorting a column, which means the follow-ups that actually happen are the ones you happen to remember.

    It does not travel. Pinch-zooming a grid in a driveway between appointments is miserable, so the real workflow becomes "write it on paper, type it in tonight" — and the typing-in is the step that gets skipped on a Friday.

    It has no idea a policy lapsed. Status in a sheet is whatever was true the last time someone updated a cell. For a persistency business, that is the expensive one: a chargeback often starts as a draft that failed while nobody was looking.

    It cannot be shared without being broken. Two people in one file is one overwritten column away from an argument, and a manager asking "what did the team do today" turns into a group text with four different formats of answer.

    Job by job

    The jobSpreadsheetBroker 360
    Store client detailsFine, as long as one person maintains itA contact record with history, files and policies attached
    Tell you who to call todayYou remember, or you sort a columnCheck-ins and follow-up reminders; automated on the Plus tiers
    Plan tomorrow's routeCopy addresses into a maps app, one at a timeLead map and route planning
    Work from a kitchen tablePinch-zooming a grid on a phoneAn app built for the phone and iPad you already carry
    Quote a client on the spotNot possibleMulti-carrier quoting inside the in-home presentation
    Keep the in-force book straightA tab you update when you rememberPolicy manager: carrier, product, premium, status and file history
    Track approaches and presentationsAnother tab to keep up to date by handLogged as you go; feeds the dashboard and leaderboards
    Show a manager what happened todayEmail the file, or a group textLive team view and leaderboards on a Manager plan
    Survive a lost laptopDepends entirely on where the file livesSynced across devices and the web dashboard
    Ad-hoc maths on a comp gridExcellent — this is what it is forNot its job; use a sheet or our free calculators

    Scroll the table sideways on a small screen.

    Keep the sheet. Try moving the book.

    Run both side by side for the length of the trial and see which one you actually reach for. Either way you end the week knowing, rather than guessing, and it costs nothing to find out.

    Moving a book across without losing anything

    Four steps. The upload is the quick part; the tidy-up beforehand is what makes it painless.

    1. 1

      Get to one row per client

      Flatten merged cells and multi-row headers, split "name" into something consistent, and make sure each row has a phone, an email and an address where you have them. If a client has three policies, that is three policy rows or three columns — just be consistent about which.

    2. 2

      Normalise the messy columns

      One date format. One spelling per carrier and per product. Premiums as plain numbers without currency symbols mixed in. This is the half hour that decides whether the import feels magic or feels like a chore.

    3. 3

      Export to CSV and upload it

      Upload the file in Broker 360, review the matches it finds, and commit them as clients and policies. Nothing is deleted on your side — keep the original file. Watch a book upload.

    4. 4

      Or let us do the first load

      Agent Plus and Manager Plus include a done-for-you contact import and setup, which is worth it if your sheet has five years of history and three different conventions in it.

    What Broker 360 doesn't do

    What Broker 360 doesn't do

    • It is not a spreadsheet. There are no free-form formulas, pivot tables or custom columns — you work with clients, policies, activity and teams as the app models them.
    • It costs money: $49 a month for the Agent plan where a spreadsheet costs nothing but your time. If your book is a dozen clients, the sheet may genuinely still win.
    • It does not reconcile carrier commission statements or do your accounting. Keep the sheet, or use our free calculators to model advances and overrides.
    • It does not supply leads, and it is not a carrier submission portal.
    • Medicare features are agent-facing workflow only: tracking enrollments, plan changes and signed Scopes of Appointment. Broker 360 does not advise consumers on plans and is not affiliated with or endorsed by any government agency.

    Spreadsheet-to-CRM questions

    What a sheet does well, what it costs you, and exactly how to move a book without losing anything.

    What is wrong with running my book in a spreadsheet?
    Nothing, until it has to do four jobs at once. A spreadsheet is a good ledger and a poor reminder system: it will not tell you who to call today, it will not map tomorrow's appointments, it does not travel well on a phone at a kitchen table, and it has no idea that a policy lapsed.
    What does a spreadsheet actually do better?
    Ad-hoc maths and one-off analysis. If you want to model a comp grid, split a bonus or sanity-check a carrier statement, a blank sheet beats any fixed screen. Plenty of agents keep a spreadsheet for exactly that after they move the book itself into a CRM.
    Will I lose my data if I switch?
    No. Export the sheet to CSV, make sure each row has a name, phone, email, address and policy details, then upload it in Broker 360 and review the matches before committing. Keep the original file; nothing is deleted on your side by importing it.
    How long does it take to move a book across?
    The upload itself takes minutes. The work is in the cleanup beforehand: one row per client, consistent date formats, and carrier and product names spelled the same way throughout. Agent Plus and Manager Plus include a done-for-you import where our team does that first load with you.
    What does it cost compared with a free spreadsheet?
    The Agent plan is $49 per month, which is where the honest comparison sits: a spreadsheet costs nothing but your time, and the question is whether the follow-ups, route planning, quoting and policy tracking you get back are worth that. Start with a 7-day free trial and decide with your own book loaded.
    Can a team share one spreadsheet instead?
    You can, and it works until somebody overwrites a column or a manager wants to know what happened today. Broker 360 gives each agent their own book, rolls activity up to a manager's team view, and ranks it on a leaderboard without anyone maintaining a shared file.

    Keep the spreadsheet. Move the book.

    Export the file, upload it, and run a week with both open if it makes you feel better. At the end of the trial you will know which one you actually reach for, and finding that out costs you $0.

    Keep the sheet open alongside it for the seven days and decide at the end.

    Broker 360 is rated 4.6★ from 53 ratings on the App Store (as of October 2026).