For agents

    After the Sale: A Follow-Up Schedule for Insurance Clients

    · 5 min read

    After you write a policy, plan on about eight touches in the first year: a thank-you the day of the sale, a check that the paperwork arrived, a heads-up before the first payment, check-ins at three, six and nine months, a birthday message, and an anniversary review. Knowing the schedule is the easy part. Sending every one of them is where most agents fall off.

    Why most agents stop after the sale

    “Most agents log the sale and move on to the next house.”
    Broker 360 founder

    It makes sense. You have more doors to knock and more calls to make, and the client who already signed feels like a finished job. But think about the last ten people you wrote. One of them has grown kids. One has a neighbor or a friend who has been putting off coverage for years. If they never hear from you again, none of those people ever hear your name.

    A check-in at six months, a call before a birthday, a simple ask for a referral: every one of those depends on you remembering to do it. That's the real problem. It isn't effort. It's memory. The client who already signed is the one who slips.

    “Insurance is a compounding business. Every policy you write should make the next one easier through referrals, through add-ons, and clients who stick around.”
    Broker 360 founder

    The first-year schedule

    Each touch is small. The point is that all of them happen, in order, for every client.

    1. The day of the sale: a thank-you

      Thank them, remind them who you are, and give them a number to save. If you only do one thing on this list, do this one.

    2. The first couple of weeks: did the paperwork arrive?

      Clients get nervous when nothing shows up in the mail. A short check that the policy arrived answers the question before it turns into a cancellation.

    3. Just before the first payment: a heads-up

      Let them know the first draft is coming. A client who is surprised by a payment is a client who calls the carrier instead of you.

    4. Three months: the first check-in

      Ask how things are going and whether they have any questions about the policy. No pitch.

    5. Six months: check in and ask for a referral

      By now they trust you. Ask if there's anyone in their family or circle you could help the same way.

    6. Nine months: check in about their coverage

      Ask whether anything has changed: a new grandchild, a health scare, a friend who passed. Those are the moments people realize they need more coverage.

    7. Their birthday: just a happy birthday

      Nothing to sell. People remember who remembered.

    8. One year: the anniversary review

      Go over the policy, the beneficiaries and whether the coverage still fits. It's the natural time to talk about adding on.

    What to say

    Keep it short and keep it in your own voice. These are starting points; rewrite them so they sound like you.

    • Thank-you: "Hi [name], it's [your name]. Thank you for trusting me with your coverage today. Save this number and text me any time you have a question."
    • Paperwork: "Hi [name], just checking that your policy paperwork arrived. If anything is missing, let me know and I'll take care of it."
    • Check-in: "Hi [name], it's [your name]. How is everything going with your coverage? Is there anyone in your family I could help the way I helped you?"
    • Birthday: "Happy birthday, [name]! Hope it's a great one."

    A few ground rules

    • Get the client's permission before you text them, and follow the texting and marketing rules for your state and the products you sell. Medicare has its own rules, so check with your upline or compliance team before you reach out to Medicare clients.
    • Stop when someone asks you to stop, and make a note of it.
    • Keep every touch in one place so you can see who heard from you and when.

    Why consistency beats clever

    You don't need a perfect message. You need the message to go out. Plenty of agents have a long list of clients they haven't talked to in years: they did the hard work of building the relationship, then lost track of it as the book grew. When those clients finally hear from their agent again, some want to add coverage and some want to review what they have. The opportunities were in the book the whole time.

    That's all a follow-up schedule does. It won't make you a better closer. It makes sure the work you already did keeps paying off.

    Three ways to run it

    1. By hand

      A calendar, a spreadsheet and phone reminders. It works while your book is small, and it breaks the day your book is bigger than your memory.

    2. With reminders

      A CRM that tells you who is due for a call or a text. Better, but you still send each one yourself.

    3. Automatically

      Broker 360's Agent Plus plan runs a schedule like this for you once you log the sale: a welcome text right away, a payment reminder before the first draft, check-ins at three, six, nine and twelve months that ask for referrals and add-ons, a birthday message and an annual policy review, plus reminders when a call is due.

    Broker 360

    Every client, every policy, every follow-up in one app.

    Log your activity and sales from your phone, keep your whole book searchable, and with Agent Plus, let the follow-up go out on a schedule after every sale.

    Questions agents ask

    How often should I contact a client after selling a policy?
    Plan on about eight touches in the first year: a thank-you, a paperwork check, a heads-up before the first payment, check-ins at three, six and nine months, a birthday message and an anniversary review. After that, keep the birthday and anniversary every year with a check-in or two in between.
    Should I call or text my insurance clients?
    Text for the small touches like thank-yous, paperwork checks and birthdays. Call when you want a real conversation, like an anniversary review or a coverage question.
    When should I ask a client for referrals?
    At the table after the sale, and again at your check-ins once the client trusts you. Ask for one or two specific people rather than anyone they know.
    Do I need permission to text my clients?
    Yes. Get the client's permission before you text them and follow the texting and marketing rules for your state and the products you sell. Medicare has its own marketing rules, so check with your upline or compliance team first.