For agents

    How to Ask for Referrals When You Hate Asking

    · 4 min read

    Asking for a referral feels awkward because it feels like taking something you haven't earned. Flip it around: you're offering the people your client cares about the same help you just gave them. Ask for one or two specific people, ask at the table and again at your check-ins, and build the ask into your routine so it doesn't depend on how brave you feel that day.

    The moment at the table

    “If you're an insurance broker who doesn't like asking for referrals, I get it. I've been there and I'm not going to tell you just to get over it.”
    Broker 360 founder

    You know the moment. The application is done, the client is relaxed, and you can feel the referral ask coming. Then you decide not to do it. Maybe you tell yourself you'll ask next time. Next time usually doesn't come.

    Why the ask feels wrong

    “Asking for referrals is always awkward. It always can feel like you're asking for something that maybe you didn't earn.”
    Broker 360 founder

    That feeling usually comes from timing. If the sale is the end of the relationship, the ask really does feel like taking: you got the policy, and now you want more. If the sale is the start of the relationship, the ask feels different.

    The reframe: you're about to give, not take

    “Asking feels like you're taking, but if you know that you're about to give and give to this client in the way that you're following up with them and taking care of them, and you know you'll be able to take care of their family and friends the same way, it makes the ask so much easier.”
    Broker 360 founder

    When you know you're going to check in, remember their birthday and be there when they call with a question, you aren't asking for a favor. You're offering the same care to the people they love. That's an easy thing to offer.

    What to actually say

    “Hey, who are one or two people that you know that I can help out with the same way that I just helped you?”
    Broker 360 founder

    Notice what that does. It asks for one or two people, not "anyone you know", which is easy to brush off. It ties the ask to what you just did together. And it's about helping, not selling. A few variations to make your own:

    • At the table: "You've taken care of your family today. Who are one or two people you'd want to have the same peace of mind?"
    • On a check-in call: "I'm glad everything's going well. Is there anyone in your family or on your street I should be helping too?"
    • When they thank you: "It's what I'm here for. If you know one or two people who'd want the same help, I'd be glad to talk with them."

    Think about who's around them. Your client has grown kids, siblings, neighbors and friends, and some of them have been putting off coverage for years. A name you get today is someone you would never have reached on your own.

    When to ask

    1. At the table

      Right after the application, while the client feels good about what they just did. Make it part of how every presentation ends, not a decision you make in the moment.

    2. At your check-ins

      Three, six, nine and twelve months after the sale. By then you've followed through on what you promised, and the ask is easier for both of you.

    3. When something changes

      A new grandchild, a move, a friend who just lost someone. Those are the moments people think about their family's coverage.

    Build it into the system so it doesn't depend on nerve

    The agents who get the most referrals aren't the boldest ones. They're the ones who ask every time because it's part of the routine. Put the ask in your presentation, put check-ins on your calendar, and write down every name you get so you follow up on it.

    In Broker 360, Agent Plus check-ins go out at three, six, nine and twelve months after the sale and ask your clients for referrals and add-ons for you, so the ask happens even in a week you're too busy to think about it.

    Broker 360

    Every client, every policy, every follow-up in one app.

    Log your activity and sales from your phone, keep your whole book searchable, and with Agent Plus, let the follow-up go out on a schedule after every sale.

    Questions agents ask

    How do I ask for referrals without feeling pushy?
    Ask for one or two specific people, tie the ask to the help you just gave, and make it about helping their family and friends the same way. If you follow up after the sale, you're offering a service, not asking for a favor.
    When is the best time to ask an insurance client for a referral?
    Right after the application at the table, and again at your check-ins in the first year, once you've followed through on what you promised.
    How many referrals should I ask for?
    One or two. A specific number is easier to answer than "anyone you know".